Saturday, October 29, 2011

Silent Spring

This excerpt from Rachel Carson's Silent Spring talks about the effect of pesticides.  The effect on the birds and their birth and development is a negative one.  It tells about the death rate among birds that were exposed to DDT.  It also talks about a trickle down effect and how the DDT effects not just birds, but other animals and people.  The claim of this excerpt is about the effect of pesticides on the environment.  The claim is fairly efective with the large amounts of data and numbers to back it up.  Much like the last story, this one can lose readers who do not understand the context or are confused by the number.  With todays use of pesticides, i dont think it is an issue on the current environment.  Today's applications are much more focused on where the problem lies, not over the entire area.  The use today isn't nearly as hazardous to animals and people as the past.

Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Omnivore's Dilemma

Pollan's claim is for people to look at the sources of their food.  He wants them to know about what they are eating and that the normal food food they eat might not have a natural origin.  This claim is fairly effective.  It is effective to those that understand the technical bits, but for the general reader, the complexity of the writing might hurt the effectiveness.  I think that the way that these farms run, returning to grass feed might not be an option, especially for the quality of beef the consumers demand.  This has not changed my feeling towards eating beef too much, as I knew about a few of these things.

Friday, October 14, 2011

Oct 14th Readings


      It  depends on the  meaning of harmful.  A wolf can be more harmful to a person.  But in terms of the environment I think the wolf is better, it cleans up everything and its population is much smaller.  I dont not entirely agree with the statement about the country losing its wilderness.  there is still a wilderness for a lot of animals and plants, but in terms of the wolf's ecology, their wilderness might be lost.  I think bass uses italics to put emphasis on certain ideas.  he uses them frequently to try to make a strong argument.  he uses quotations that make a more sarcastic statement.  The similarities between the two stories is about how the deer have a far greater impact on the environment then the wolf.